Published on June 29, 2023 by Eoghan Ryan.
Ryan, E. (2023, June 29). Ethical Implications of ChatGPT. Scribbr. Retrieved July 7, 2023, from https://www.scribbr.com/ai-tools/chatgpt-ethics/
The increasing popularity of generative AI tools like ChatGPT raises questions about the ethical implications of their use. Key concerns include:
Biased and inaccurate outputs
Plagiarism and cheating
Understanding these issues can help you use AI tools responsibly.
Ethical implication 1: Biased and inaccurate outputs
ChatGPT was trained on a vast number of sources, some of which contain obvious biases. As a result, the tool sometimes produces outputs that reflect these biases (e.g., racial or gender stereotypes). The tool has also been criticized for its tendency to produce inaccurate or false information as though it were factual.
Furthermore, there is a lack of transparency about the sources the tool was trained on and about its decision-making processes (i.e., it’s unclear how it arrives at certain outputs).
Ethical implication 2: Privacy violations
ChatGPT conversations are stored for the purposes of training future models. Therefore, if a user inputs personal details (or false information) about themselves or another person into ChatGPT, it may be reproduced by the tool in its later outputs.
Users should be careful about the information they choose to input and refrain from including sensitive information about themselves or others.
To prevent the content of your conversations from being included in future training material, you can manually disable your chat history and request that OpenAI delete your past conversations.
Ethical implication 3: Plagiarism and cheating
In academic contexts, ChatGPT and other AI tools may be used to cheat. This can be intentional or unintentional. Some of the ways ChatGPT may be used to cheat include:
Passing off AI-generated content as original work
Paraphrasing plagiarized content and passing it off as original work
Fabricating data to support your research
Using ChatGPT to cheat is academically dishonest and is prohibited by university guidelines. Furthermore, it’s unfair to students who didn’t cheat and is potentially dangerous (e.g., if published work contains incorrect information or fabricated data).
AI detectors may be used to detect this offense.
Ethical implication 4: Copyright infringement
ChatGPT is trained on a variety of sources, many of which are protected by copyright. As a result, ChatGPT may reproduce copyrighted content in its outputs. This is not only an ethical issue but also a potential legal issue.
OpenAI states that users are responsible for the content of outputs, meaning that users may be liable for copyright issues that arise from the use (e.g., publication) of ChatGPT outputs.
This is problematic because ChatGPT is unable to provide citations for the sources it was trained on, so it can be difficult for the user to know when copyright has been infringed.
How to use ChatGPT ethically
Follow your institution’s guidelines: Consult your university’s policy about the use of AI writing tools and stay up to date with any changes.
Acknowledge your use of ChatGPT: Be transparent about how you’ve used the tool. This may involve citing ChatGPT or providing a link to your conversation.
Critically evaluate outputs: Don’t take ChatGPT outputs at face value. Always verify information using a credible source.
Use it as a source of inspiration: If allowed by your institution, use AI-generated outputs as a source of guidance rather than as a substitute for your own work (e.g., use ChatGPT to generate potential research questions).
Note: Universities and other institutions are still developing their stances on how ChatGPT and similar tools may be used. Always follow your institution’s guidelines over any suggestions you read online. Check out our [Scribbr] guide to current university policies on AI writing for more information.